Menus
- Happy Hour
- Cocktails
- Beer and Wine
- Shareable Starters
- Lobster Rolls
- Boils & Dinners
- Maines
- Sides
- Soft Drinks
- Kids
- Desserts
Available Monday-Friday, 4-6pm*
Dine-in only, no takeout
-
Oysters
Chef's Selection
$1
-
Frozen Margarita
Classic Marg done right!
$10
-
Jack Frost
silver rum, coconut and pineapple served frozen and blue with a candy cane rim
$10
-
Talea Peachberry Punch
Sour, 16oz Draft
Glass $5
Pitcher $20
-
Montauk The Surf Beer
12oz Can, Golden ale, Low ABV Crushers!
Can $5
Bucket $20
-
Montauk Bucket
5 different Montauk beers in 12 oz cans. 1 Cold day Ipa, 1 Pils, 1 Pumpkin, 1 Summer ale, 1 WaveChaser IPA
$20
-
Gansett Lager
Draft
Glass $5
Bucket (cans) $20
-
Rose
From California
Glass $5
Bottle $24
-
Chardonnay
Line 39 Chardonnay
Glass $5
Bottle $24
*excluding all holidays
Seasonal Cocktails
-
Santa Clausmopolitan
Served in an ornament! Deep Eddy cranberry vodka, lime, triple sec
$10
-
Jack Frost
Served frozen and blue! rum, pineapple, coconut with a candy cane rim
$10
-
Spiked Hot Toddy
Jack Daniels Apple, baking spices, ginger honey syrup
$14
Specialty Cocktails
-
Blueberry Thyme
Bluecoat Gin, St Germain, blueberry, lemon, club
$15
-
Oaxacan Penicillin
Mezcal, ginger honey juice, lime and lemon
$16
-
Painkiller
Goslings rum, pineapple and orange, coconut, nutmeg
$17
-
Rye Tai
Sazarac Rye, orgeat, pineapple and lemon, Peychaud's bitters
$16
-
Torched Collins
Gin, lemon, Pimento dram, torched rosemary
$15
-
White Cosmo
Vodka, white cranberry, lime, gold shimmer
$15
-
Piccolo Pomelo
Tequila, Campari, grapefruit and lime, simple
$15
-
Frozen Margarita
blanco tequila, lime, triple sec
$14
RHLP Favorites
-
LOBSTER CLAW BLOODY MARY
Maine lobster meat, olives and pickle spear, Titos and our housemade Bloody Mary mix
$17
-
Blood Orange Margarita
Blood orange puree shaken with Tequila, Triple sec and lime juice. **Try It spicy**
$15
-
Hibiscus Mojito
Homemade hibiscus syrup, rum, lime juice
$14
-
Smokin' Jane
Widow Jane oak and applewood aged rye whiskey stirred until chilled with apple blossom bitters and maple syrup. topped with a candied orange slice and SMOKED table side. *Try with widow jane 10 year aged*
$16
-
Smoky Paloma
Mezcal, lime juice and cointreau topped with grapefruit juice
$16
-
Red Hook
A cocktail created right here in Red Hook. Sazerac Rye, sweet vermouth and luxardo liqueur stirred and served up
$16
-
TIPSY LEMONADES
Cherry Bourbon | Blueberry Whiskey | Cherry Vodka
$14
-
Virgin Mojito
Muddled mint and lime with a touch of sweet topped off with soda water.
$7
Crowd Pleasers!
-
Margarita Pitcher
Classic, Hibiscus or Blood Orange. Also available spicy!
$55
-
Mojito Pitcher
Choice of classic or hibiscus. Can be done spirit-free.
$55
After Dinner Cocktails
-
Cold Brew Martini
Cold brew shaken with vodka and a mix of almond and hazelnut liqueur.
$15
-
Amaretto Sidecar
Disaronno amaretto blended with Grand Mariner and lemon juice
$15
Seasonal Beers
-
Flagship Wolfhound Nitro Oyster Stout
Nitro Oyster Stout 5.4% ABV 16oz Draft - Roasted barley united with chocolate rye, midnight wheat, and flaked oats gives this brew dark color and roasted flavor while providing a smooth, silky mouthfeel and rich body.
$9
-
Montauk Pumpkin Beer
Pumpkin Beer 5.7% - 16oz Draft . just the right amount of spices along with subtle hop aromas, this beer highlights the time of year just perfectly.
$8
Beer Flights
A taste of RHLP. 3 New England and 3 NY breweries combined on 1 flight designed for a perfect tasting experience.-
Flight from NY to NE
Coney Island Pilsner, Sloop Juice bomb IPA, Talea Peach Berry Punch, Narragansett Lager, Allagash White Wheat ale, Radiant Pig Gangster Duck red ale
$36
Draft Beer
All of our draft beer is either from New York or New England-
MAINE BEER COMPANY LUNCH
IPA 7% ABV - 10 oz Draft. East Coast version of West Coast Style IPA 97 score from BeerAdvocate #6 Ranked IPA-American
$9
-
Talea Peach berry punch
6% wheat sour, This fruit-forward Berliner Weisse-style sour is dry with medium-body. Peach and blackberry forward with supporting notes of tropical passion fruit.
Pint $9
Pitcher $32
Tower $54
-
BluePoint Toasted Lager
American Amber, ABV 5.5% - 16oz Draft. Six different grains to create a perfect balanced flavor of malt and a long-lasting smooth finish that’s meant to be enjoyed year-round
Pint $8
Pitcher $30
Tower $51
-
Von Trapp Munich Dunkel
Dark Lager, ABV 5.7% - 16oz draft Creamy, toffee aromas balance the bitterness of Munich malts in our roasted brown lager. Although dark in color, Dunkel is medium in body and finishes dry and clean.
Pint $9
Pitcher $32
Tower $54
-
SLOOP
Juice Bomb NEIPA 6.4% ABV - 16oz Draft An explosively unfiltered IPA, golden in color. Bursting with citrus flavor that balances with a touch of bitterness on the finish.
Pint $9
Pitcher $32
Tower $54
-
Radiant Pig Gangster Duck
American Red Ale 6.2% ABV - 16oz Draft, Intense citrus and stone fruits dominate the nose, yet the bitterness from the hops is balanced by Belgian and American crystal malts
Pint $9
Pitcher $32
-
Coney Island Mermaid
Pilsner 5.2% ABV - 16oz Draft. Light-bodied, crisp-drinking, nicely hopped lager. A heavy-handed addition of rye malt adds a mild spiciness, which is balanced by a light, fruity, floral hop aroma.
Pint $8
Pitcher $30
Tower $51
-
Allagash White
Wheat Beer 5.1% ABV 16 oz American interpretation of a traditional Belgian wheat beer. Generous wheat spiced with coriander, orange peel. Refreshing, slightly cloudy. 93 score from Beer Advocate
Pint $9
Pitcher $32
Tower $54
-
DOWNEAST CIDER
Cider 5.1% ABV - 16 oz Draft. An unfiltered cider made from 100% local New England apples. Full-bodied and smooth finish.
Pint $8
Pitcher $30
Tower $51
-
NARRAGANSETT LAGER
Lager 5% ABV - 16 oz Draft or Can. "Hi Neighbor! Have a 'Gansett!"
Pint $7
Pitcher $28
Tower $46
Packaged Beer
For our International and Domestic Selection-
Guava Gose by Collective Arts
4.9% ABV 12oz Can. The base Gose has a balanced lemony tartness from the presence of malted wheat, Himalayan pink sea salt and coriander with a flowery bright smoothness from guava. The end result is a perfect balance of tart, sweet, and sour, leaving you refreshed and wanting more
$8
-
Stone Buenaveza
Salt & Lime Lager , ABV 4.7%, 12 oz can. Light Lager with the perfect balance of Tart and acidity. Why a lime wedge when we can just have lime added!
$7
-
Truly
5% ABV. Gluten Free. Punch variety flavors available!
Single Flavor $5
Bucket of 5 Mixed Flavors $20
-
CORONA
$7
-
Modelo
$7
-
NARRAGANSETT LAGER
Lager 5% ABV - 16 oz Draft or Can. "Hi Neighbor! Have a 'Gansett!"
$7
-
STELLA ARTOIS
4.8%. ABV 12 oz can
$8
-
ATHLETIC BREWING CO
Non-Alcoholic
Golden Dawn, Golden Ale $6
Cerveza Athletica, Light copper $6
-
Montauk Brewing co
All 12oz Cans, Buckets available!
The Surf Beer Golden Ale 4.5% ABV $7
Summer Ale Pale Ale 5.6% ABV $5
Cold Day Ipa 6.7% ABV $7
Wave Chaser Ipa 6.4% ABV $7
Pils, Pilsner 5.4% ABV $7
Watermelon Session Ale 4.9% ABV $5
Variety Bucket $25
Wine
-
LA MARCA PROSECCO
Italy
Bottle $32
Glass $7
-
Le Rime Pinot Grigio
Italy
Bottle $30
Glass $7
-
STARBOROUGH SAUVIGNON BLANC
New Zealand
Bottle $32
Glass $8
-
Line 39 Chardonnay
richly flavored, medium-bodied wine with hints of oak and lush tropical and stone fruit flavors on the palate. Pairs great with seafood.
Glass $8
Bottle $32
-
Chateau Souverain
Cabernet Sauvignon California 2018
Bottle $35
Glass $9
-
Robert Hall Cabernet Sauvignon
Paso Robles 2020 California
Glass $10
Bottle $40
-
Fleur de mer Rose
French Rose
Glass $9
Bottle $35
-
Proverb Rose
California Rose
Bottle $25
Glass $7
LOBSTERSIZE IT!
add 2, 3 or 4 oz of lobster meat
($14,$21, $28)
November Specials
Specials to complement November Wine Month-
Charcuterie Plate
chorizo, proscuttio, mini kunick cheese, manchego, toasted ciabatta, almonds, jam and mustard
$20
-
Bavarian Pretzels and Beer Cheese
3 - 8inch Bavarian Pretzels served with homemade beer cheese
$9
-
Lobster Butter Popcorn
House popped popcorn topped with lobster butter and a sprinkle of old bay
$5
Raw Bar
-
SHRIMP COCKTAIL
6 large shrimp served with a side of cocktail sauce
$23
-
Little Necks Clams
Cape Cod Sweet, buttery and mild salt
$1.50
-
East Coast Oyster
Wellfleet-MA Sharp brine with plump meat and a rounded seaweed finish.
$3.50
-
West Coast Oyster
Kusshi, Baynes Sound, British Columbia Slight briny and sweet, with a mild fruit finish
$4
-
Maine Lobster Tail
Split, chilled and served in shell with a side of tarragon aioli
$19
-
The Minnow
1/2 dz mixed oysters, 1/2 dz littleneck clams, 3 chilled shrimp, 1/2 chilled lobster tail. Served with mignonette, cocktail sauce, horseradish and tarragon aioli
$55
-
The Downeaster
1 dz mixed oysters, 1 dz littleneck clams, 6 chilled shrimp, 1 split lobster tail. Served with mignonette, cocktail sauce, horseradish and tarragon aioli
$105
Chowdah
-
NEW ENGLAND
Creamy old-fashioned clam chowder
Cup $6.50
Bowl $8.50
Toasted Ciabatta $1.50
-
Manhattan
Our take on traditional Manhattan Clam Chowder. Tomato broth based clam chowder with potatoes vegetables and fresh herbs
Cup $6.50
Bowl $8.50
Toasted Ciabatta $1.50
-
Lobster Bisque
Traditional & creamy
Cup $6.50
Bowl $8.50
Toasted Ciabatta $1.50
Shareables
-
Steamed Clams
1 dozen wild caught Little Neck Clams from Cape Cod, steamed and served with a side of drawn butter and lemon
$18
-
Mussels and Ciabatta
1 pound of sautéed mussels in your choice of garlic herb or cajun garlic butter served with toasted ciabatta. A great starter to share
$21
-
LOBSTER CHEESE FRIES
fries topped with our four-cheese sauce and Maine lobster...you're gonna need a fork
$23
-
CRISPY BRUSSELS SPROUTS
With lobster caramel sauce
$14
-
OLD BAY SHRIMP
thrown around with a bunch of Old Bay and served with cocktail sauce...finger-lickin' good
$17
-
FRIED CALAMARI
locally caught off Rhode Island, with lemon aioli, pepper relish
$18
-
LOBSTER MAC AND CHEESE
Maine lobster and organic pasta in our four-cheese sauce
Small $23
Large $34
-
Fried Shrimp
8 large shrimp seasoned in old bay flour served golden brown with spicy pepper mayo
$16
-
HOT CRAB DIP
hot lump crab dip served with our homemade Old Bay potato chips...a little crabby, a little cheesy, a lot of yummy
$20
-
FRIED PICKLES
beer-battered and served with chipotle mayo
$11
-
Garlic Biscuits
4 Buttermilk Biscuits slathered in garlic butter.
$8
-
Crab Cake Sliders
3 of 'em on martins buns with jalapeno carrot slaw
$18
*Warning: Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs, may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions
*A 20% Service fee will be added to parties of 6 or more.
LOBSTERSIZE IT!
Add 2, 3, or 4 oz lobster to any roll!
($14, $21, $28)
Lobster Rolls
All rolls served on an authentic New England, top split, buttered and toasted bun - w/fries, salad, coleslaw, potato salad, or chips.-
THE CLASSIC
"Maine Style" lobster salad tossed with a touch of mayo and topped with paprika and scallions
$32
-
6oz Classic
6oz of fresh Maine lobster meat prepared either classic with your choice of side
$42
-
THE CONNECTICUT
lobster poached in butter and lemon served warm and tossed with paprika and scallions
$32
-
6oz Connecticut
6oz of fresh Maine lobster poached in butter
$42
-
THE BLT
lobster salad, chipotle mayo, and applewood smoked bacon topped with paprika and scallions
$34
-
6oz BLT
6oz of fresh Maine lobster tossed in lemon mayo, crisp applewood bacon, chipotle mayo
$44
-
FRIED LOBSTER ROLL
fried lobster tossed in lobster caramel sauce with kewpie mayo
$32
*Warning: Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs, may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions
*A 20% Service fee will be added to parties of 6 or more.
LOBSTERSIZE IT
add 2, 3, or 4 oz of lobster meat to any dish
($14,$21, $28)
Boils & Dinners
All served with corn & potatoes-
THE POUNDSTER
1 lb Dungeness Crab legs, 1.5lb lobster, clams, mussels, shrimp, andouille sausage tossed in garlic seasoned butter
$99
-
THE LOBSTER DINNER
Swimming-In-The-Tank-Fresh Maine lobster (1.5lbs)
$42
-
CRAB DINNER
1 lb crab of your choice
Snow $45
King $110
Dungeness $40
-
PORTLANDER
1 lb shrimp, 1 dozen clams, tossed in garlic parsley butter
$38
-
NEW ENGLAND SEAFOOD BOIL
Fresh clams, mussels, shrimp, sausage, tossed in old bay garlic butter
$30
-
ADD TO ANY BOIL
1.5 lb Lobster $37
1 lb Shrimp $23
1 lb Mussels $14
1 lb King crab $105
1 lb Snow crab $53
1lb Dungeness $35
1 dozen Clams $17
Andouille sausage (pork or chicken) $6
*Warning: Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs, may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions
*A 20% Service fee will be added to parties of 6 or more.
LOBSTERSIZE IT
add 2, 3, or 4 oz of lobster meat to any dish
($14,$21, $28)
FROM THE SEA
Served with your choice of potato salad, slaw, fries, green salad, or chips *except for pasta-
FISH AND CHIPS
Fresh, wild-caught Atlantic white fish, beer-battered
$23
-
LOBSTER GRILLED CHEESE
Lobster, bacon, tomato, and cheddar
$25
-
Fish Tacos
fried haddock, poblano crema, pickled carrot and jalapeños
$23
-
Seafood Bucatini
sautéed mussels, clams and shrimp, garlic butter, parmesan cheese
$30
LAND HO
Served with your choice of potato salad, slaw, fries, green salad, or chips-
HOOK BURGER*
1/2 lb dry-aged prime blend, lettuce, tomato, special sauce
$24
Add bacon $3
Add Cheese $2
Make it Surf and Turf $14
-
OLD BAY FRIED CHICKEN SANDWICH
Lettuce, tomato, local brine pickles, and lemon aioli
$23
SALADS
-
COBBSTER SALAD
Bacon, blue cheese, tomatoes, egg, crispy onions, avocado with ranch dressing
Lobster $33
Chicken $23
Shrimp $31
Salmon $29
-
LOBSTER CAESAR SALAD
Classic Caesar served with large leaf romaine
Lobster $33
Chicken $23
Shrimp $31
Salmon $29
-
Harvest Salad
Baby spinach, butternut squash, craisins, pecans, farro, apple cider mustard vinaigrette
Lobster $34
Chicken $23
Shrimp $31
Salmon $29
*Warning: Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs, may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions
*A 20% Service fee will be added to parties of 6 or more.
Sides
-
MAC & CHEESE
Small $9
Large $13
-
CHEESE FRIES
$10
-
FRIES
$8
-
POTATO SALAD
$5
-
GREEN SALAD
$7
-
CAESAR SALAD
$6
-
SLAW
$5
-
CORN
$4
Sodas
-
MAINE ROOT ORGANIC SODA
Blueberry and Root Beer
$4
-
COKE
$3
-
DIET COKE
$3
-
Sprite
$3
-
GINGER ALE
$3
-
CLUB SODA
$2
LEMONADE AND ICED TEA
-
HOMEMADE LEMONADE
$5
Make it Hibiscus $3
-
ICED TEA
$4
HOT BEVERAGES
-
DRIP COFFEE
$2
-
ESPRESSO
$3
-
LATTE
$5
-
CAPPUCCINO
$5
-
HOT TEA
$2
LOBSTERSIZE IT
add 2, 3 or 4 oz of lobster meat
($14, $21, $28)
Kids
Ages 12 and Under-
CHICKEN TENDERS AND FRIES
House-made tenders
$12
-
KIDS HAMBURGER AND FRIES
Plain $12
With Cheese $13
-
GRILLED CHEESE AND FRIES
Simple and delicious. American cheese melted on our New England Style Rolls
$9
-
MAC AND CHEESE
Organic pasta with our five-cheese sauce
$9
-
Hot Dog
all beef hot dog and fries
$9
-
BUTTERED NOODLES
The classic for a picky eater (or a simple comfort dish) using organic pasta
$7
*Warning: Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs, may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions
*A 20% Service fee will be added to parties of 6 or more.
Desserts
-
BANANA PUDDING
Topped with Nilla Wafers
$6
-
STEVE'S KEY LIME PIE
A neighborhood staple. Individual Pies
$8
-
S'MORES IN A GLASS
The campfire favorite turned into a single-serve mousse perfect for any time of year.
$6
-
Pumpkin Mousse
Layered pumpkin mousse with graham cracker crumbs, salted caramel, pecans
$6
-
Churros
Tossed in cinnamon sugar served with salted caramel, chocolate and Maine blueberry compote
$11
-
ROOT BEER FLOAT
For the kids--or just the kid in you! A classic using organic Maine Root Beer and vanilla bean gelato
$8
-
Blueberry Float
Vanilla Bean Gelato and Maine Organic Blueberry
$8
-
Scoop of Gelato
Featuring Dolce Brooklyn, our neighbors of Red Hook. Choice of Vanilla Bean or Blueberry Cream
$3.50