Menus
- Lobster Week
- Happy Hour
- September Specials
- Cocktails
- Frozen Drinks
- Beer and Wine
- Shareable Starters
- Lobster Rolls
- Boils & Dinners
- Maines
- Sides
- Soft Drinks
- Kids
- Desserts
Lobster Dinner Add-Ons
add to your Lobster Dinner for the full experience!-
Lobster
1.5lb Maine Lobster
$25
-
King Crab Legs
1/2 lb $52.50
1 lb $105
-
Snow Crab Legs
1/2 lb $30
1 lb $53
-
Dungenes Crab Legs
1/2 lb $20
1 lb $35
-
New England Seafood Boil
Sausage, Clams, Mussels & Shrimp
Half $15
Full $25
-
Shrimp
1/2 lb $14
1 lb $23
-
Mussels
1/2 lb $9
1 lb $14
-
Clams
Top-Neck
1/2 lb $10
1 lb $17
-
Andouille Sausage
$6
-
Chicken Sausage
$6
Drink Specials
-
Deep Eddy's Watermelon Frose
Deep Eddy Vodka, Watermelon juice, Rose Wine, and Lemon juice, Served in a MASON JAR THAT IS YOURS TO KEEP!
$10
-
Pina Colada
Frozen Pina colada (Rum)
$10
-
Frozen Margarita
Tequila, Triple sec and Lime juice
$10
-
Montauk Surf Beer
12 oz can, Golden ale, 4.5%ABV
Can $5
Bucket (5 cans) $20
-
Proverb Rose
California
$5
-
Narragansett Lager
16oz Can
Can $5
Bucket $20
-
Truly
Choice of flavor -Lime -Grapefruit -Lemon -Citrus Squeeze
Can $5
Bucket $20
-
Line 39 Chardonnay
Perfect with a lobster!
$5
Available Monday-Friday, 4-6pm*
Dine-in only, no takeout
-
Oysters
Chef's Selection
$1
-
FROSE
Rose, fresh watermelon juice, vodka and lemon juice, served FROZEN
$10
-
Frozen Margarita
Classic Marg done right!
$10
-
Frozen Pina Colada
silver rum, coconut and pineapple
$10
-
Gansett Lager
Draft
$5
-
Rose
From California
$5
*excluding all holidays
Beer and Wine
-
Montauk Surf Beer
12 oz can, Golden Ale , 4.5% ABV. Light and balanced, Great paired with fish and shellfish!
$7
Group Cocktails
-
Ocean in a bowl
Rum punch made with Blue curacao, Pineapple juice, Tangerine puree, Orgeat and Lime juice. Topped with gummy sharks and lobsters. This drink is for groups 2+ served in a BIG GLASS
$55
Seasonal Cocktails
-
Blood Orange Margarita
Blood orange puree shaken with Tequila, Triple sec and lime juice. **Try It spicy**
$15
Pitcher $55
-
Poolside
Cucumber Gin, Fresh Mint and Lime juice with a touch of club soda to finish. Perfectly light and refreshing!
$14
-
Its Blueberry Thyme
Bluecoat gin, St Germain shaken with Blueberry compote, lemon juice, Topped with soda water
$15
-
Flowers & Berries
Vodka and St Germain with fresh muddled strawberries. Fruity and refreshing
$15
-
Hibiscus Mojito
Homemade hibiscus syrup, rum, lime juice
$14
-
Ocean View
vodka, pineapple, orange, lime and orgeat.
$14
Fishbowls & Pitchers
-
Ocean in a Bowl
Rum punch made with Blue curacao, Pineapple juice, Tangerine puree, Orgeat and Lime juice. Topped with gummy sharks and lobsters. This drink is for groups 2+ served in a BIG GLASS
$55
-
Margarita Pitcher
Classic, Hibiscus or Blood Orange. Also available spicy!
$55
Specialty Cocktails
-
Smokin' Jane
Widow Jane oak and applewood aged rye whiskey stirred until chilled with apple blossom bitters and maple syrup. topped with a candied orange slice and SMOKED table side. *Try with widow jane 10 year aged*
$16
-
Smoky Paloma
Mezcal, lime juice and cointreau topped with grapefruit juice
$16
-
TIPSY LEMONADES
Cherry Bourbon | Blueberry Whiskey | Cherry Vodka
$14
-
Virgin Mojito
Muddled mint and lime with a touch of sweet topped off with soda water.
$7
Pitcher $25
Classic Cocktails
-
LOBSTER CLAW BLOODY MARY
Maine lobster meat, olives and pickle spear, Titos and our housemade Bloody Mary mix
$17
-
Mai Tai
Goslings and light rum, lime juice, Cointreau and orgeat
$16
-
Old Cuban
Bacardi, lime, mint, splash of prosecco
$14
-
Dark & Stormy
Goslings rum and lime juice topped with Fever Tree ginger beer
$14
-
Red Hook
A cocktail created right here in Red Hook. Sazerac Rye, sweet vermouth and luxardo liqueur stirred and served up
$16
-
Martinez
Fords gin, sweet vermouth, luxardo
$16
-
Negroni
Fords gin, campari, sweet vermouth
$15
After Dinner Cocktails
-
Cold Brew Martini
Cold brew shaken with vodka and a mix of almond and hazelnut liqueur.
$15
-
Amaretto Sidecar
Disaronno amaretto blended with Grand Mariner and lemon juice
$15
-
Frose
Fresh watermelon juice, lemon, rose wine and vodka!
$14
-
Margarita
Classic marg frozen to perfection
$14
-
Piña Colada
Classic Piña Colada. Try a float of Goslings Rum, Hennessy. for only $5!
$14
Seasonal Beers
-
Brooklyn Oktoberfest
Brooklyn Oktoberfest - Marzen Style Lager, 5.5%abv , full-bodied and malty, with a bready aroma and light, brisk hop bitterness.
$8
-
Montauk Watermelon Session
Session IPA 4.9% - 16oz Draft . Golden clear on the pour with a nice head and some lacing. Mild carbonation. Slight fruity aroma, and crisp taste that is both fruity and slightly hoppy. Hint of bitter on the finish.
$8
Beer Flights
A taste of RHLP. 3 New England and 3 NY breweries combined on 1 flight designed for a perfect tasting experience.-
Flight from NY to NE
Coney Island Pilsner, Sloop Juice bomb IPA, Talea Peach Berry Punch, Narragansett Lager, Allagash White Wheat ale Oxbow Farmhouse Saison
$36
Draft Beer
All of our draft beer is either from New York or New England-
MAINE BEER COMPANY LUNCH
IPA 7% ABV - 10 oz Draft. East Coast version of West Coast Style IPA 97 score from BeerAdvocate #6 Ranked IPA-American
$9
-
Talea Peach berry punch
6% wheat sour, This fruit-forward Berliner Weisse-style sour is dry with medium-body. Peach and blackberry forward with supporting notes of tropical passion fruit.
Pint $9
Pitcher $32
Tower $54
-
BluePoint Toasted Lager
American Amber, ABV 5.5% - 16oz Draft. Six different grains to create a perfect balanced flavor of malt and a long-lasting smooth finish that’s meant to be enjoyed year-round
Pint $8
Pitcher $30
Tower $51
-
Von Trapp Kölsch
Kölsch, ABV 5% - 16oz draft Dry-hopped using select American varietals, this hop forward golden ale is unfiltered with notes of citrus and tropical fruit.
Pint $9
Pitcher $32
Tower $54
-
SLOOP
Juice Bomb NEIPA 6.4% ABV - 16oz Draft An explosively unfiltered IPA, golden in color. Bursting with citrus flavor that balances with a touch of bitterness on the finish.
Pint $9
Pitcher $32
Tower $54
-
Oxbow
Saison 6% ABV - 16oz Draft, Gold, tart and slightly funky, made with only american hops and saison yeast.
Pint $9
Pitcher $32
-
Coney Island Mermaid
Pilsner 5.2% ABV - 16oz Draft. Light-bodied, crisp-drinking, nicely hopped lager. A heavy-handed addition of rye malt adds a mild spiciness, which is balanced by a light, fruity, floral hop aroma.
Pint $8
Pitcher $30
Tower $51
-
Allagash White
Wheat Beer 5.1% ABV 16 oz American interpretation of a traditional Belgian wheat beer. Generous wheat spiced with coriander, orange peel. Refreshing, slightly cloudy. 93 score from Beer Advocate
Pint $9
Pitcher $32
Tower $54
-
DOWNEAST CIDER
Cider 5.1% ABV - 16 oz Draft. An unfiltered cider made from 100% local New England apples. Full-bodied and smooth finish.
Pint $8
Pitcher $30
Tower $51
-
NARRAGANSETT LAGER
Lager 5% ABV - 16 oz Draft or Can. "Hi Neighbor! Have a 'Gansett!"
Pint $7
Pitcher $28
Tower $46
Packaged Beer
For our International and Domestic Selection-
Guava Gose by Collective Arts
4.9% ABV 12oz Can. The base Gose has a balanced lemony tartness from the presence of malted wheat, Himalayan pink sea salt and coriander with a flowery bright smoothness from guava. The end result is a perfect balance of tart, sweet, and sour, leaving you refreshed and wanting more
$8
-
Five Borough Gridlock NEIPA
6.5% ABV 16oz Can- Hazy IPA offering a tropical traffic jam of flavor, a smooth, full-bodied brew — bumper-to-bumper deliciousness.
$9
-
Stone Buenaveza
Salt & Lime Lager , ABV 4.7%, 12 oz can. Light Lager with the perfect balance of Tart and acidity. Why a lime wedge when we can just have lime added!
$7
-
Montauk Summer Ale
5.6% ABV, 12oz can, American Pale ale
$7
-
Truly
5% ABV. Gluten Free. Punch variety flavors available!
Single Flavor $5
Bucket of 5 Mixed Flavors $20
-
CORONA
$7
-
Modelo
$7
-
NARRAGANSETT LAGER
Lager 5% ABV - 16 oz Draft or Can. "Hi Neighbor! Have a 'Gansett!"
$7
-
STELLA ARTOIS
4.8%. ABV 12 oz can
$8
-
ATHLETIC BREWING CO GOLDEN DAWN
Non-Alcoholic
$6
-
Montauk Surf Beer
4.5% ABV, Golden ale, Light and goes perfect with seafood! Surfs up!
$7
Wine
-
LA MARCA PROSECCO
Italy
Bottle $32
Glass $7
-
Le Rime Pinot Grigio
Italy
Bottle $30
Glass $7
-
STARBOROUGH SAUVIGNON BLANC
New Zealand
Bottle $32
Glass $8
-
Line 39 Chardonnay
richly flavored, medium-bodied wine with hints of oak and lush tropical and stone fruit flavors on the palate. Pairs great with seafood.
Glass $8
Bottle $32
-
Chateau Souverain
Cabernet Sauvignon California 2018
Bottle $35
Glass $9
-
Robert Hall Cabernet Sauvignon
Paso Robles 2020 California
Glass $10
Bottle $40
-
Fleur de mer Rose
French Rose
Glass $9
Bottle $35
-
Proverb Rose
California Rose
Bottle $25
Glass $7
LOBSTERSIZE IT!
add 2, 3 or 4 oz of lobster meat
($14,$21, $28)
Raw Bar
-
SHRIMP COCKTAIL
6 large shrimp served with a side of cocktail sauce
$23
-
Little Necks Clams
Cape Cod Sweet, buttery and mild salt
$1.50
-
East Coast Oyster
Wellfleet-MA Sharp brine with plump meat and a rounded seaweed finish.
$3.50
-
West Coast Oyster
Kusshi, Baynes Sound, British Columbia Slight briny and sweet, with a mild fruit finish
$4
-
Maine Lobster Tail
Split, chilled and served in shell with a side of tarragon aioli
$19
-
The Minnow
1/2 dz mixed oysters, 1/2 dz littleneck clams, 3 chilled shrimp, 1/2 chilled lobster tail. Served with mignonette, cocktail sauce, horseradish and tarragon aioli
$55
-
The Downeaster
1 dz mixed oysters, 1 dz littleneck clams, 6 chilled shrimp, 1 split lobster tail. Served with mignonette, cocktail sauce, horseradish and tarragon aioli
$105
Chowdah
-
NEW ENGLAND
Creamy old-fashioned clam chowder
Cup $6.50
Bowl $8.50
Toasted Ciabatta $1.50
-
Manhattan
Our take on traditional Manhattan Clam Chowder. Tomato broth based clam chowder with potatoes vegetables and fresh herbs
Cup $6.50
Bowl $8.50
Toasted Ciabatta $1.50
-
Lobster Bisque
Traditional & creamy
Cup $6.50
Bowl $8.50
Toasted Ciabatta $1.50
Shareables
-
Steamed Clams
1 dozen wild caught Little Neck Clams from Cape Cod, steamed and served with a side of drawn butter and lemon
$18
-
Mussels and Ciabatta
1 pound of sautéed mussels in your choice of garlic herb or cajun garlic butter served with toasted ciabatta. A great starter to share
$21
-
LOBSTER CHEESE FRIES
fries topped with our four-cheese sauce and Maine lobster...you're gonna need a fork
$23
-
CRISPY BRUSSELS SPROUTS
With lobster caramel sauce
$14
-
OLD BAY SHRIMP
thrown around with a bunch of Old Bay and served with cocktail sauce...finger-lickin' good
$17
-
FRIED CALAMARI
locally caught off Rhode Island, with lemon aioli, pepper relish
$18
-
LOBSTER MAC AND CHEESE
Maine lobster and organic pasta in our four-cheese sauce
Small $23
Large $34
-
Fried Shrimp
8 large shrimp seasoned in old bay flour served golden brown with spicy pepper mayo
$16
-
HOT CRAB DIP
hot lump crab dip served with our homemade Old Bay potato chips...a little crabby, a little cheesy, a lot of yummy
$20
-
FRIED PICKLES
beer-battered and served with chipotle mayo
$11
-
Garlic Biscuits
4 Buttermilk Biscuits slathered in garlic butter.
$8
-
Crab Cake Sliders
3 of 'em on martins buns with jalapeno carrot slaw
$18
*Warning: Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs, may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions
*A 20% Service fee will be added to parties of 6 or more.
LOBSTERSIZE IT!
Add 2, 3, or 4 oz lobster to any roll!
($14, $21, $28)
Lobster Rolls
All rolls served on an authentic New England, top split, buttered and toasted bun - w/fries, salad, coleslaw, potato salad, or chips.-
THE CLASSIC
"Maine Style" lobster salad tossed with a touch of mayo and topped with paprika and scallions
$32
-
6oz Classic
6oz of fresh Maine lobster meat prepared either classic with your choice of side
$42
-
THE CONNECTICUT
lobster poached in butter and lemon served warm and tossed with paprika and scallions
$32
-
6oz Conneticut
6oz of fresh Maine lobster poached in butter
$42
-
THE BLT
lobster salad, chipotle mayo, and applewood smoked bacon topped with paprika and scallions
$34
-
6oz BLT
6oz of fresh Maine lobster tossed in lemon mayo, crisp applewood bacon, chipotle mayo
$44
-
FRIED LOBSTER ROLL
fried lobster tossed in lobster caramel sauce with kewpie mayo
$32
*Warning: Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs, may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions
*A 20% Service fee will be added to parties of 6 or more.
LOBSTERSIZE IT
add 2, 3, or 4 oz of lobster meat to any dish
($14,$21, $28)
Boils & Dinners
All served with corn & potatoes-
THE POUNDSTER
1 lb Dungeness Crab legs, 1.5lb lobster, clams, mussels, shrimp, andouille sausage tossed in garlic seasoned butter
$90
-
THE LOBSTER DINNER
Swimming-In-The-Tank-Fresh Maine lobster (1.5lbs)
Market Price
-
CRAB DINNER
1 lb crab of your choice
Snow $58
King $110
Dungeness $40
-
PORTLANDER
1 lb shrimp, 1 dozen clams, tossed in garlic parsley butter
$38
-
NEW ENGLAND SEAFOOD BOIL
Fresh clams, mussels, shrimp, sausage, tossed in old bay garlic butter
$30
-
ADD TO ANY BOIL
1.5 lb Lobster $33
1 lb Shrimp $23
1 lb Mussels $14
1 lb King crab $105
1 lb Snow crab $53
1lb Dungeness $35
1 dozen Clams $17
Andouille sausage (pork or chicken) $6
*Warning: Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs, may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions
*A 20% Service fee will be added to parties of 6 or more.
LOBSTERSIZE IT
add 2, 3, or 4 oz of lobster meat to any dish
($14,$21, $28)
FROM THE SEA
Served with your choice of potato salad, slaw, fries, green salad, or chips *except for pasta-
FISH AND CHIPS
Fresh, wild-caught Atlantic white fish, beer-battered
$23
-
LOBSTER GRILLED CHEESE
Lobster, bacon, tomato, and cheddar
$25
-
Fish Tacos
fried haddock, poblano crema, pickled carrot and jalapeños
$23
-
Seafood Bucatini
sautéed mussels, clams and shrimp, garlic butter, parmesan cheese
$30
LAND HO
Served with your choice of potato salad, slaw, fries, green salad, or chips-
HOOK BURGER*
1/2 lb dry-aged prime blend, lettuce, tomato, special sauce
$24
Add bacon $3
Add Cheese $2
Make it Surf and Turf $14
-
OLD BAY FRIED CHICKEN SANDWICH
Lettuce, tomato, local brine pickles, and lemon aioli
$23
SALADS
-
COBBSTER SALAD
Bacon, blue cheese, tomatoes, egg, crispy onions, avocado with ranch dressing
Lobster $33
Chicken $23
Shrimp $31
Salmon $29
-
LOBSTER CAESAR SALAD
Classic Caesar with little gem lettuce
Lobster $33
Chicken $23
Shrimp $31
Salmon $29
-
Citrus Salad
Shaved fennel, radish, hearts of palm, avocado, citrus vinaigrette
Lobster $34
Chicken $23
Shrimp $31
Salmon $29
*Warning: Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs, may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions
*A 20% Service fee will be added to parties of 6 or more.
Sides
-
MAC & CHEESE
Small $9
Large $13
-
CHEESE FRIES
$9
-
FRIES
$7
-
POTATO SALAD
$5
-
GREEN SALAD
$7
-
CAESAR SALAD
$6
-
SLAW
$5
-
CORN
$4
Sodas
-
MAINE ROOT ORGANIC SODA
Blueberry and Root Beer
$4
-
COKE
$3
-
DIET COKE
$3
-
Sprite
$3
-
GINGER ALE
$3
-
CLUB SODA
$2
LEMONADE AND ICED TEA
-
HOMEMADE LEMONADE
$5
Make it Hibiscus $3
-
ICED TEA
$4
HOT BEVERAGES
-
DRIP COFFEE
$2
-
ESPRESSO
$3
-
LATTE
$5
-
CAPPUCCINO
$5
-
HOT TEA
$2
LOBSTERSIZE IT
add 2, 3 or 4 oz of lobster meat
($14, $21, $28)
Kids
Ages 12 and Under-
CHICKEN TENDERS AND FRIES
House-made tenders
$12
-
KIDS HAMBURGER AND FRIES
Plain $12
With Cheese $13
-
GRILLED CHEESE AND FRIES
Simple and delicious. American cheese melted on our New England Style Rolls
$9
-
MAC AND CHEESE
Organic pasta with our five-cheese sauce
$9
-
Hot Dog
all beef hot dog and fries
$9
-
BUTTERED NOODLES
The classic for a picky eater (or a simple comfort dish) using organic pasta
$7
*Warning: Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs, may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions
*A 20% Service fee will be added to parties of 6 or more.
Desserts
-
BANANA PUDDING
Topped with Nilla Wafers
$6
-
STEVE'S KEY LIME PIE
A neighborhood staple. Individual Pies
$8
-
S'MORES IN A GLASS
The campfire favorite turned into a single-serve mousse perfect for any time of year.
$6
-
Lemon Cheesecake Mousse
Light layers of lemon cheesecake filling, graham cracker crumbs, and strawberry compote topped with whipped cream and candied lemon peel
$6
-
Churros
Tossed in cinnamon sugar served with salted caramel, chocolate and Maine blueberry compote
$11
-
ROOT BEER FLOAT
For the kids--or just the kid in you! A classic using organic Maine Root Beer and vanilla bean gelato
$8
-
Blueberry Float
Vanilla Bean Gelato and Maine Organic Blueberry
$8
-
Scoop of Gelato
Featuring Dolce Brooklyn, our neighbors of Red Hook. Choice of Vanilla Bean or Blueberry Cream
$3.50